Toledo Blade articles concerning Ju'Nathan

Toledo Blade articles concerning Ju'Nathan

A Toledo boy who died last Saturday had multiple scars on his body and reportedly was disciplined by his father and stepmother the night before and the day of his death, though there were no signs of injury that could have led to his death, according to court documents and officials close to the case.

Ju'Nathan Shoulders, 7, died in Toledo Hospital after he was taken there from his home at 3535 Hilltop Blvd.

Initial reports indicated fire crews were sent to the home about 11 a.m. for a boy who was not breathing. Police were told that Ju'Nathan walked into the living room and passed out.

The Lucas County coroner's office is trying to determine the cause of his death.

"He wasn't beaten to death, I can tell you that. That would be easy to determine," said Dr. Cynthia Beisser, a Lucas County deputy coroner who is awaiting the results of toxicology tests which could pinpoint the cause of death.

The documents were submitted Tuesday to Lucas County Juvenile Court for a custody hearing for two other children in the care of the boy's father, Willie Shoulders, Jr.

Ju'Nathan's 5-year-old brother and 2-year-old sister were taken from the home and placed in the care of Lucas County Children Services.

According to the documents filed by children services, Mr. Shoulders "reported that on the evening of Feb. 10, 2006, he whipped Ju'Nathan and [his brother] because they wet themselves. [The brother] reported his stepmother, Tanisha Shoulders, whipped Ju'Nathan and him on Feb. 11, 2006."

They also state an examination of Ju'Nathan's body "revealed in excess of thirty linear and loop-shaped welts and scars."

The 5-year-old brother and 2-year-old sister also had multiple linear and loop-shaped welts and scars on their bodies of varying ages when examined in a Children Services clinic, according to the documents.

The report also cited a coroner's verbal preliminary report indicating "an impact bruise on the top of his head that is consistent with the report that he had been jumping on a bed and struck his head. There were no internal injuries that would look like a beating."

Dr. Beisser said the welts and scars on Ju'Nathan's body appeared old, and a head bruise, which included some blood under the scalp, was not a fatal wound.

"There was no evidence of a fatal beating," she said.

Mr. Shoulders could not be reached for comment last night.

Toledo police Detective Vince Mauro, who said he has heard conflicting reports of what happened before the boy's death, said he will decide how to proceed with his investigation once he receives the coroner's report.

"There is a possibility that there was child abuse that had gone on prior to Saturday, but now the focus is on determining the cause of death," he said.

Dean Sparks, executive director of children services, said his agency had no indication of prior abuse with regard to the children, and said every service provider involved with the case was supportive of Mr. Shoulders as a parent.

He said while he personally objects to it, corporal punishment is allowed under state law.

"Just because the child has an injury, even if it was an injury caused by the father, doesn't necessarily mean cause for removal," he said. "There are so many 'what ifs'."

"We remove a child if they are in imminent risk of harm," he said.

Mr. Sparks acknowledged an incident in January at Kaiser Elementary School in which Ju'Nathan had marks on his body and his agency was called. He said it was his understanding the boy and his sibling both blamed the marks on another student.

"Now that we know what we know, would I leave a kid with 30 loop marks with the father? No, I wouldn't," he added.

Contact Tad Vezner at:
tvezner@theblade.com
or 419-724-6050.

Article published Friday, December 15, 2006

Toledo man gets 4 years in abuse of his 3 children

By MARK REITER
BLADE STAFF WRITER

The beatings that Willie Shoulders, Jr., inflicted on his children, including a 7-year-old boy who died shortly after he was taken from their home, went far beyond discipline, a Lucas County Common Pleas Court judge said yesterday.

In sentencing Shoulders to four years in prison, Judge Charles Wittenberg said the welts and scars found on his children were evidence of physical abuse, not discipline, as he claimed.

"The defendant beat the children with an electrical cord. He did it severely, often, and harshly enough to cause multiple scars on the legs, buttocks, and backs of the children," the judge said.

The charges stem from an investigation that began after Ju'Nathan, 7, collapsed on Feb. 11 in Shoulder's home at 3535 Hilltop Blvd. He died later that day after being taken to Toledo Hospital.

Ju'Nathan's 6-year-old brother, Ju'Zarian, and 3-year-old sister, Ju'Kizja, were found to have multiple welts and scars, and they were taken from the home and placed in the care of Lucas County Children Services.

Michael Loisel, a county assistant prosecutor, said the abuse began about four months before the child's death.

"Discipline and abuse are two different things," he said.

Shoulders, 27, entered pleas of no contest and was found guilty on Nov. 27 on two counts of child endangering for physically abusing Ju'Nathan and Ju'Zarian.

He was also indicted on child endangering in connection with the youngest child, but that charge was dismissed as part of the plea agreement.

He was not charged in connection with the death of Ju'Nathan because the child's cause of death could not be established by the county coroner's office.

Investigators said Shoulders disciplined his sons the day before Ju'Nathan died for urinating on themselves, and he admitted that he had "whipped" Ju'Nathan seven times for the incident.

Shoulders struggled to hold back tears as he read a statement he wrote on a legal pad in the courtroom while waiting to be sentenced.

He said he disciplined his children by "God's will'' to show them a better place and life.

"I was overwhelmed with problems. I am deeply sorry for what has happened. It was never my intent to harm my children in any way," he said.

Shoulders had a prior misdemeanor conviction for child endangering.

According to prosecutors and the defendant's attorney, Jane Roman, the children were returned to the custody of the defendant and his wife after he was sentenced and convicted in that case.

MARK OF THE BEAST

Please get in touch with any comments or reactions to my site.